Telegram is where most forex signals are shared, and it is also where most signal scams happen. Some groups are honest but bad at trading. Others are not really signal services at all: they use signals as bait to sell “investment plans”, account management or fake trading dashboards.
Here’s how to tell them apart. The checks below come from what victims describe, and from a year in which our tracking system recorded 10,285 signals from 39 Telegram channels and checked each against real prices (the full study). ForexSignals.io runs its own signal channel, so we have an interest in this subject; apply every check to us too.
The short answer
A forex signals group is very likely a scam if it does any of these:
- messages you first, especially about money, VIP access or “a special opportunity”;
- offers an investment plan, account management or a guaranteed or fixed return;
- asks you to send money to a person or a crypto wallet instead of paying through a checkout;
- asks for a fee, tax or “verification” payment before you can withdraw profits;
- wants your broker login, seed phrase or remote access to your device.
A group can avoid all five and still be poor value. That’s what checks 6 to 10 are for.
1. The admin who messages you first
The most common scam starts minutes after you join a real channel. Someone with the same name and photo as the admin sends you a private message: a free VIP trial, a “personal account manager”, a limited offer.
Telegram lets anyone copy a display name and profile photo. What can’t be copied is the @username. Check it character by character against the list on the provider’s own website: scammers use extra underscores, swapped letters, a digit in place of a letter, or “official” in a different position.
Our rule: ForexSignals.io never messages anyone first about money, upgrades or VIP. Our only channel is t.me/Official_ForexSignals, and VIP is sold only through @FXSio_Bot. The official channels page lists every account that is really us.
2. Investment plans and “we trade for you”
This is the scam that costs people the most. The pitch: send $500 (or $5,000) and the team will trade it for you, with a weekly return of 20%, 50% or “100% in 7 days”. A dashboard then shows the balance growing.
A signal service does not need your money. It sends trade ideas, and you place them in your own account at your own regulated broker. Managing other people’s money needs a licence in almost every country, and licensed managers don’t recruit through Telegram DMs. If a signals group offers an investment plan, treat it as a scam.
3. Fees before you can withdraw
The last stage of an investment scam. When you ask for your “profits”, you’re told to pay first: a withdrawal fee, a tax, an anti-money-laundering check, an upgrade to a higher tier. Each payment is followed by another request, and questions are met with pressure or a block.
The profits were never real. Stop paying, save every message and transaction ID, and report it (see what to do if you’ve been scammed).
4. Win rates that are too good
“95% accuracy”, “no losing weeks”, “10% a day”. We measured this. On the 4,313 signals where the 39 channels posted a result, they claimed 95% were winners. Checked against real prices, 63% were.
Real trading has losing trades, losing weeks and drawdowns. A provider who claims otherwise is either hiding losses or taking risks that will eventually blow up an account.
5. Losses that are never mentioned
The gap between 95% and 63% wasn’t mainly invented wins. It was silence. Of 3,164 signals that hit their stop loss, channels mentioned 40. The other 3,124 just disappeared from the feed, while “TP hit” posts went out every few hours.
Before paying anyone, count the stop-outs you see them announce in a month. If there are none, losses are being left out.
6. Signals posted after the move, edited or deleted
Three tricks that make a record look better than it is:
- Posted after the move. 19% of the signals we recorded went out when price had already passed the first target. They look perfect in screenshots and can’t be traded.
- Edited later. 16% were edited more than 10 minutes after posting, after subscribers had acted on the original. Telegram marks these as “edited”.
- Deleted. On average 13% of a channel’s posts had been deleted by the time we recorded it. Three of the best-looking channels had deleted 42%, 55% and 66% of theirs.
7. No stop loss
Every signal should state its stop loss at the same time as the entry. “SL: will update”, “manage your own risk” or no stop at all means the signal can’t be measured, and a single bad trade can wipe out weeks of small wins. A few channels in our study posted almost no stops.
8. Pressure and urgency
“Only 3 places left”, “price doubles tonight”, “deposit within the hour to unlock the bonus”. Urgency is there to stop you from checking. A legitimate service will still be there tomorrow.
9. A broker you’re told to use, with strings attached
Some groups require you to open an account with a particular broker, often offshore, sometimes with a large deposit bonus that blocks withdrawals until you’ve traded a huge volume. Being sent to a broker through an affiliate link isn’t a scam in itself, but check the broker’s licence on the regulator’s own website, never through a link in the chat. And never let anyone “connect” to your account to trade for you.
10. Results you can’t check
Screenshots are easy to fake and easy to cherry-pick. A provider worth paying should let you check its record:
- signals posted before the move, with entry, stop and target;
- losses listed next to wins, with dates;
- a record kept by something other than the provider’s own posts, such as a third-party tracker or price data.
This is why ForexSignals.io publishes every VIP trade, losses included, with results worked out from 1-minute market prices rather than from our own posts.
Telegram groups vs channels
Most “signal groups” are really Telegram channels, where only the provider can post. That matters: in a group, anyone can post, so a scammer inside the group can pose as an admin, drop fake testimonials or post “I just withdrew $3,000” messages. If you’re in a group where members are constantly posting profits and recommending a manager, assume some of those members are part of the scam.
Can a signals group be legit but still lose money?
Yes, and it’s common. Of 27 channels we tracked with enough results to judge, 17 lost money after a normal spread, and taking every signal from every channel would have lost overall. “Not a scam” and “worth paying for” are separate questions. Our guide to whether forex signals are worth it and the two-week test cover the second one.
What to do if you’ve been scammed
- Stop paying. No further fee will release your money.
- Save the evidence: usernames (with the @), chat exports, wallet addresses, transaction IDs and dates.
- Call your bank or card issuer if you paid by card or bank transfer. Card payments can sometimes be disputed. Crypto transfers usually can’t be reversed.
- Report the accounts in Telegram (open the profile, then Report) and to your national fraud reporting service, for example the FBI’s IC3 in the US or Scamwatch in Australia.
- Ignore “recovery” offers. People who lost money are often contacted by someone promising to get it back for a fee. That is a second scam.
If the scammer used our name, tell us through the official channel so we can warn others.
A quick checklist before you join or pay
- Did I find the channel myself, from the provider’s own website?
- Does the @username match that website exactly?
- Has anyone messaged me privately about money, a manager or an investment plan?
- Does every signal have a stop loss, posted with the entry?
- Have I seen losing trades announced?
- Am I paying through a checkout or bot at a fixed price, not to a person or wallet?
- Is my broker licensed, and did I check that on the regulator’s own website?
Whatever service you use, size every trade with a stop loss and a fixed risk percentage.
Frequently asked questions
How can I tell if a forex signals group is a scam?
Check five things before you pay or follow anyone. Every signal has a stop loss posted with the entry. Losing trades are announced, not only wins. Nobody messages you privately about money. There are no investment plans, account management or guaranteed returns. And the channel is the exact one linked from the provider's own website. A group that fails any one of these is not worth the risk.
Is a forex signals group that asks for a deposit or investment a scam?
Almost always. A signal service sells trade ideas; you trade them in your own account with your own regulated broker. Any group that asks you to send money to a wallet or a person so it can trade for you, or offers an investment plan with fixed returns, is running an unlicensed investment scheme or an outright scam.
Why does a group ask me to pay a fee before I can withdraw profits?
Because the profits don't exist. Fees, taxes or verification charges before a withdrawal are the final stage of an investment scam: the dashboard showing your gains is fake, and each payment is followed by another request. Stop paying, keep the evidence and report it.
Are the win rates Telegram signal channels advertise real?
Rarely. We tracked 39 channels for a year. On the 4,313 signals where channels posted a result, they claimed 95% won; checked against real prices, 63% did. Of 3,164 signals that hit their stop loss, channels mentioned 40.
How do I know if I'm talking to the real admin of a signals channel?
Assume you aren't if they message you first. Scammers copy a channel's name, photo and pinned posts, then contact its new members. Real providers list their official usernames on their website; check the exact @username (not the display name) against that list, character by character.
I was scammed by a signals group. Can I get my money back?
Contact your bank or card issuer straight away, since card payments can sometimes be disputed; crypto transfers usually can't be reversed. Report the accounts in Telegram and to your national fraud reporting service. Be very wary of anyone who then offers to recover your money for a fee: "recovery" services are a common second scam aimed at victims.
Is a signals group that only accepts crypto a scam?
Not by itself, since some legitimate providers accept crypto. It becomes a warning sign when crypto is the only option, the payment goes to a personal wallet given in a private chat, or there is no checkout or receipt. A legitimate service takes payment through a checkout or bot with a fixed price.
Is ForexSignals.io a scam?
No. ForexSignals.io publishes trade ideas on Telegram and has never offered investment plans, taken deposits or managed accounts. People who were offered those using our name were dealing with impersonators. Our official accounts are listed on the official channels page, and every VIP trade, losses included, is published on our site.